Casebook Home | Twelve Winters Miscellany
The Interplay of Trauma and Identity
Minha Iman
Ted Morrissey’s short story “Vox Humana” can be psychoanalyzed via its associations with trauma and identity. The narrative explores themes of cultural trauma, reflecting the characters’ struggles with their past and societal expectations. Morrissey’s use of fragmented storytelling mirrors the disjointed experiences of those affected by trauma, emphasizing how such experiences distort one’s perception of reality. Additionally, the characters represent aspects of the Freudian psyche, the id, ego, and superego—revealing their internal conflicts and suppressed desires. This interplay between personal and collective trauma enriches the story’s depth psychologically.
“Vox Humana,” which translates to “human voice,” summarizes the essence of human experience through its characters and their struggles. The story intertwines personal narratives with cultural reflections, illustrating how individual trauma is often influenced by collective experiences. Morrissey employs a non-linear narrative style that mirrors the chaotic nature of memory and trauma, allowing readers to engage with the character’s psyche on a deeper level.
- Cultural Trauma
One of the central issues in “Vox Humana” is cultural trauma, which refers to the collective suffering experienced by a group of people due to historical events. The character’s struggle with their identities shaped by cultural expectations and past traumas. For instance, Annette Wilson’s recollections of family dynamics reveal how generational trauma affects individual behavior and identity formation. The narrative suggests that personal experiences cannot be separated from the larger societal context, highlighting how cultural history infuses individual psyches.
- Fragmented Narration
Morrissey’s use of fragmented narration serves as a reflection of traumatic memory. The disjointed timeline forces readers to piece together events, mimicking how trauma can disrupt memory and perception. This technique effectively conveys the confusion and chaos experienced by individuals dealing with trauma. For example, moments from childhood intermingled with present-day reflections illustrate how unresolved past experiences continue to influence current behavior and relationships.
- The Id, Ego, and Superego
Freud’s structural model of the psyche posits three components: the id, ego, and superego. The id represents primal desires and impulses, the ego mediates between the id and the external world, and the superego internalizes societal norms and morality. In “Vox Humana,” Henry’s id is evident in his impulsive and sometimes reckless behavior. He drinks heavily, and struggles to maintain stable relationships. These actions can be seen as attempts to escape the pain of his past, seeking immediate gratification and avoiding deeper emotional connections. His ego, on the other hand, is constantly at work, trying to balance his desires with societal expectations. He strives to appear normal and successful, to conform to the image of a returning war hero. However, his efforts to suppress his trauma often lead to anxiety and guilt. The superego, the moral compass of the psyche, is also at play. Henry feels a sense of responsibility for the lives lost in the war, a burden that weighs heavily on his conscience. This internalized morality prevents him from fully letting go of the past and moving forward with his life.
Freudian psychoanalysis provides a useful framework for understanding the characters in “Vox Humana.” The interplay between the id (instinctual desires), ego (reality), and superego (moral conscience) is evident in the protagonist’s internal conflicts. The id manifests through impulsive actions driven by unmet desires, while the superego represents societal expectations that impose guilt and shame. For instance, moments of rebellion against hereditary expectations highlight the struggle between these three components. Annette’s desire for freedom clashes with deep-rooted cultural norms, leading to feelings of guilt when pursuing subjective happiness. This internal conflict illustrates how deeply embedded societal pressures can distort self-perception and hinder personal growth.
- Defense Mechanisms
The character’s employ various defense mechanisms to cope with their traumas. Denial is prevalent as character’s refuse to confront painful memories or acknowledge their impact on current relationships. This avoidance creates a cycle of repression that ultimately intensifies their struggles. Additionally, prediction occurs when characters attribute their insecurities onto others, allowing them to deflect responsibility for their feelings. In one instance, a character blames external circumstances for their unhappiness rather than confronting their own choices. This projection serves as a shield against self-reflection but ultimately hinders genuine connection with others. Morrissey’s portrayal of these defense mechanisms underscores the complexity of human psychology in navigating trauma.
- Symbolism and the Unconscious
The story is rich in symbolism, which can be interpreted through a psychoanalytic lens. The recurring motif of fire, for example, represents both the destructive power of war and the transformative potential of the unconscious. The burning building in Henry’s dream symbolizes the traumatic experiences that continue to consume him.
The character of the mysterious woman, who appears in Henry’s dreams and waking life, can be seen as an archetypal figure, representing both desire and danger. She may symbolize the part of Henry’s psyche that yearns for connection and intimacy, but also the fear of vulnerability and the potential for further trauma.
- Cultural Identity
Identity plays a crucial role in “Vox Humana,” particularly regarding how cultural backgrounds shape individual experiences. The protagonist’s struggle with cultural identity is evident in their attempts to reconcile personal desires with familial expectations. This tension reflects broader societal issues surrounding assimilation and cultural preservation. The story illustrates how characters oscillate between embracing their heritage and rejecting it in pursuit of self-sufficiency. For example, moments of cultural celebration juxtaposed with feelings of alienation highlight this internal conflict. Morrissey effectively captures the nuanced experience of individuals caught between two worlds—one rooted in tradition and another striving for modernity.
- Personal Identity
The quest for personal identity is further complicated by trauma. Characters often grapple with feelings of inadequacy stemming from past experiences that shape their self-worth. The protagonist’s journey toward self-acceptance is marked by moments of self-examination that reveal deep-seated insecurities. For instance, encounters with family members trigger memories that force the protagonist to confront unresolved issues related to self-identity. These interactions serve as catalysts for growth, pushing the protagonist toward greater self-awareness despite initial resistance. Morrissey’s exploration of identity emphasizes that understanding oneself is an ongoing process influenced by both internal struggles and external relationships.
- Impact of Trauma on Relationships
The effects of trauma extend beyond individual experiences; they significantly influence interpersonal relationships within the short story “Vox Humana.” Characters often struggle to connect authentically due to unresolved issues stemming from their pasts. This disconnection manifests in strained family dynamics and friendships characterized by misunderstanding and resentment. For example, moments of conflict between family members reveal how unaddressed grievances perpetuate cycles of pain within relationships. Characters may lash out or withdraw emotionally as coping mechanisms rather than engaging in open communication about their feelings. Morrissey illustrates how trauma can create barriers to intimacy, leaving individuals feeling isolated even among loved ones.
- Healing Through Connection
Despite these challenges, moments of connection emerge as potential avenues for healing throughout the narrative. Characters who confront their traumas together often find solace in shared experiences, fostering empathy and understanding. These interactions highlight the importance of vulnerability in rebuilding relationships strained by past hurts. In one emotional scene, a character opens up about their struggles during a heartfelt conversation with a friend. This exchange serves as a turning point that allows both individuals to confront their vulnerabilities together—a powerful reminder that healing often occurs within supportive relationships.
- The Unconscious and the Return of the Repressed
“Vox Humana” is a poignant exploration of the psychological impact of war, particularly the way trauma can be repressed and resurface in unexpected ways. The story’s protagonist, Henry, returns from the Korean War seemingly unharmed, yet his dreams and waking life are haunted by the horrors of his past. Freud theorized that traumatic experiences can be repressed into the unconscious mind as a defense mechanism. However, these repressed memories can resurface in dreams, slips of the tongue, or other forms of psychological disturbance. In Henry’s case, the war’s horrors manifest in his dreams as a recurring nightmare, where he is trapped in a burning building, unable to escape. This dream symbolizes the overwhelming nature of his trauma, a psychological fire that continues to consume him.
Ted Morrissey’s “Vox Humana” offers a rich exploration of trauma, identity, and interpersonal relationships through its intricate narrative structure and psychological depth. This psychoanalytic exploration will examine the character’s psychological settings, their interactions, and the broader societal implications presented in the story. By utilizing Freudian concepts and examining cultural trauma, we can gain a deeper understanding of the characters’ motivations and the overarching message of the narrative. The fragmented storytelling mirrors the chaos of memory associated with trauma while emphasizing how personal narratives are intertwined with collective histories. As characters navigate their internal conflicts and seek connection amidst pain, Morrissey’s work underscores the resilience of the human spirit in confronting adversity.
▪ ▪ ▪
Minha Iman is an undergraduate student in the Department of English UGS at the National University of Modern Languages. She’s currently in her 8th semester. She is recognized for her hardworking, passionate, intelligent, thoughtful, and sincere approach to her studies.
Twelve Winters 